How to Pick the Right Immigration Lawyer

At some point almost everyone on a visa asks this question... Maybe your employer's attorney handles your H-1B but you have a question about a family member. Maybe you're starting a family-based case, or you got an RFE and want a second opinion.

Whatever the situation, picking the right legal counsel starts with one very critical, and obvious thing: making sure the person is actually licensed to give you immigration legal advice. Sounds silly right? I promise, it is overlooked more than you’d think!

Who Can Legally Give You Immigration Advice?

Under federal law, only authorized representatives can provide legal advice or prepare applications for immigration benefits.

While the vast majority of cases are handled by licensed attorneys in good standing, the Department of Justice (DOJ) also authorizes accredited representatives who work for recognized, non-profit organizations. Supervised law students and law graduates can also provide legal advice under strict conditions. Other individuals, such as a relative or a foreign official, may be permitted to accompany you to an interview as an "other representative," but they cannot file a formal notice of appearance or manage your case.

Who Cannot (this is important!)

"Notarios," notary publics, immigration consultants and businesses can't give you immigration legal advice unless they fall under one of the defined categories of authorized providers above. Someone who isn't authorized may be able to help with things like reading a form to you, translating, or writing down your answers, and USCIS says they should only charge a small fee and shouldn't claim special knowledge of immigration law.

Please remember this, because it is rampant in the immigration world. I see it ALL the time on social media, especially in the EB-1 realm: If someone promises a result or says they have a special connection: walk away, and speak with a licensed immigration attorney.

How to Check Before You Hire

  1. 1. Ask to see the attorney's current license, then confirm it with the state agency that regulates attorneys (the state bar, in most states). American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) Lawyer Search tool is also an excellent resource for finding immigration attorneys. Note: An attorney licensed in any U.S. state can practice immigration law anywhere, as long as they're in good standing everywhere they're licensed.

  2. Check the Department of Justice's List of Currently Disciplined Practitioners, to ensure that there have been no disciplinary actions against the practitioner in question.

  3. For an accredited representative, look them up on the DOJ's Recognition and Accreditation roster; accreditation lasts three years, so make sure it's current. When someone officially represents you before USCIS, they file a Form G-28 with your case, so you can always ask to see it.

Questions Worth Asking

Once you know they're authorized, be sure to ask questions…

  1. Do you solely practice immigration? You will find many attorneys that primarily practice other forms of law and then “dabble” in immigration. This is dangerous. Do not trust your livelihood, or status, to someone who is not an expert in immigration.

  2. How many cases like this do you handle (H-1B, PERM, family-based, an RFE)? Immigration is very complex, so you will often find attorneys that work in very specific niches. Be sure the attorney you choose is familiar with your specific type of case.

  3. Who will actually work on this case, and how will you keep me updated? Make sure that you are comfortable with the staff and systems/methods of communication they mention.

  4. How do you charge: flat fee or hourly, and what's included if USCIS sends an RFE? Many immigration law firms charge based on a flat rate, but that can change when additional requests, consultations, or in-person appearances come into play. Be sure you understand the full breadth of how they bill.

If your employer is sponsoring you, make sure you have a clear understanding of what the “dual representation agreement” means, and what constraints the attorney is bound by be cause of the relationship with the employer. Even if your name and information are on those applications, the lawyer on your H-1B or PERM is your employer's attorney first.

The more prepared you are before you speak with the attorney, the better you will feel as you move through the process.

A Place to Start

If you'd like help finding someone, Connect by InHouse Core lets you connect with a trusted attorney through our resource partner network.

Whoever you choose, ask the questions above before you move forward.

For more on staying on top of your own case before and after you hire someone, see How to Track Your USCIS Case Status Online, How to Check USCIS Processing Times, and How to keep Track of Multiple Cases at Once.

TLDR

Under federal law, only authorized representatives can provide legal advice or prepare applications for immigration benefits.

Notarios and consultants cannot.

Before you hire anyone, confirm the license with the state that regulates attorneys, check the DOJ's disciplined practitioners list, ask about experience with your exact case type, who does the work, how fees work, and, if your employer sponsors you, how dual representation works and the implications.

This post is for general information only and is not legal advice. For guidance on your specific situation, please consult a licensed immigration attorney.

The weekly recap

One email every Friday with that week's immigration news and Know-How posts, explained simply.

Sign up free
Previous
Previous

OPT vs. CPT: What's the Difference? (and the Rule That Can Cost You OPT.)

Next
Next

What Is an EAD, and How Long Does it Take to Get One?